The Gustav Sonata – Rose Tremain

Gustav Pearle lives with his mother, Emilie, in Matzlingen, Switzerland. His father, Erich, is dead. Emilie tells Gustav that his father was a hero and he died helping the Jews. As a result, Emilie dislikes Jews.


Aged five in 1947, Gustav meets Anton Zwiebel at kindergarten. Gustav’s the only person able to stop Anton from crying; he does so by repeating his mother’s phrase that ‘you have to master yourself’. Gustav and Anton become firm friends and are soon spending time with each other outside of school. This disconcerts Emilie, not only because Anton and his family are Jewish but also because they are rich while she has fallen on hard times. She worries that Gustav will expect a certain type of lifestyle because he’s been exposed to it. At six, Anton is already a talented pianist:

There was so much that had been confusing about ‘The Linden Tree’ that Gustav almost wished Anton hadn’t played it. It wasn’t just the business about the notes sounding like rustling leaves (and yet they didn’t, not quite), or the sad man who was and was not there; it was the fact of Anton being able to play this complicated song. How could he have learned it? When?

And then Gustav had another thought which he found very disturbing. He imagined that at the very time when he and Emilie were on their hands and knees cleaning the Church of Sankt Johann, on Saturday mornings, Anton was with his piano teacher. He and Emilie were scrubbing and dusting and polishing while Anton was playing music by Schubert.

The novel’s divided into three sections: the first covers Gustav’s childhood, his friendship with Anton, Anton’s attempts to become a concert pianist, and Emilie’s illnesses both mental and physical. The second goes back in time and tells the story of Emilie and Erich’s relationship, and the third travels forward to Gustav and Anton’s middle age. What connects all three sections is love.

Tremain explores love in different forms: parent and child, friends, lovers, spouses, companions. What’s particularly interesting is the disparity between the picture Emilie paints of Erich and the revelation about his past behaviour. It raises questions about coping mechanisms for those who remain after someone close to them has died and very skilfully questions whether Erich’s heroism at helping Jews remain in Switzerland is compromised through his behaviour in his private life.

Some of the books on the longlist for the Baileys Women’s Fiction Prize have caused serious debate and disagreement between the shadow panel; The Gustav Sonata is one of those books – we’re absolutely split in terms of our opinions on it. For me, it never really came off the page. The issue here, I suspect, is mine: I’ve recently been reading and writing about women writing women and the number of books by women about women which go on to win major literary prizes. (See Nicola Griffith’s analysis of this.) I was frustrated then that this is largely a book about men; it would scrape through The Bechdel Test. It’s also a very measured book and I prefer something more high wire. For balance, therefore, I’ll direct you to my fellow shadow panel member, Eric, who had a very different reaction to me.


Thanks to Chatto and Windus for the review copy.

13 thoughts on “The Gustav Sonata – Rose Tremain

  1. This is interesting and important. Thanks for linking to Nicola’s page. I wrote something in a similar vein when i analysed last year’s book reviews as summarised in The Week (you can read it here The same thing happens in book reviews. The reviews considered weightiest and of most importance, are reviews of books by men. Books by women rank, often only when they are about men. We need to keep flagging it. We need to keep reminding ourselves, because this gender bias is so deeply entrenched (in women as much as men, i suspect) that we have to be constantly reminded so that we can resist it. Nicola’s comment (in the comments section of your link) ‘the problem lies further upstream’ is spot on, sadly. To my horror, i (a self-declared feminist) sometimes find myself doing or saying things that suggest my own lack of immunity. This is why we need to be reminded, over and over. This is why we need the Bailey’s Prize to be particularly vigilant. I hope the judges read your blog…

    Liked by 1 person

    • Do you follow the Vida count, Annabel? They do the stats across the major Western publications – it’s always depressing. You’re absolutely right about the bias being entrenched in women too – I started this blog because of my own.
      The Baileys Prize isn’t too bad on this; there are very few winners by women about men, so that’s reassuring at least.
      Part of my problem is personal too, I’m so over writing about men.

      Liked by 2 people

  2. It’s so interesting to see your take on this. I’ve only read one of Tremain’s books, Trespass, which I liked but didn’t love. Funnily enough, a bookish friend was just saying the other day that she finds her very hit-and-miss, very variable from one book to the next. As a contrast, she cited Helen Dunmore, an author she thought of as being much more consistent in terms of quality.

    Liked by 1 person

    • That’s an interesting contrast; I love Dunmore and think she’s a very astute writer. I wonder if part of the power of her writing is taking a significant event but looking at it across a short timespan. I think Tremain glides over too much in The Gustav Sonata.


  3. Pingback: The Baileys Women’s Prize for Fiction Longlist 2017 | The Writes of Woman

  4. I haven’t read this one, but I can imagine that the comments you’ve made would apply to the other books of hers which I have read. She is, however, on my list of MRE authors (MustReadEverything). It is true, though, that I would turn to her in a specific kind of reading mood, prepared for immersion (as opposed to my usual reading-too-many-at-once habit) and an understated view of the world. Another with a male perspective which I thought amazing was The Road Home (but I’m not recommending it to you as it sounds as though there are some similarities with this new novel). At least you’ve got plenty of other longlisted titles that are tickling your fancy: one can’t love them all!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s