The Secret Chord – Geraldine Brooks

“I should do many things I have not done and I should not have done many of the things I have done. My heart, Natan, is as hollow as a gourd. If I am a man, as you say, then I deserve to be ranked with the lowest of men.”

The Secret Chord is the story of King David, the shepherd boy who slayed the giant Goliath and went on to lead Israel. His story’s told from the perspective of Natan, the seer, who becomes his guide and confidant prior to him becoming king.


The novel begins with Natan going to the middle-aged David and asking to set down his story so the memories of his feats will be preserved. David agrees but, to Natan’s surprise, declines to give his own account, sending Natan to see those who knew him prior to his and Natan’s relationship. His choices are also surprising: his estranged first wife, Mikhal, ‘for whom his very name was bile’; Shammah, David’s only remaining older brother, and Nizvet bat Adael, a woman who is part of Shammah’s household.

I had heard the stories, of course. There is not a person living in the Land who has not. But the stories that grow up around a king are strong vines with a fierce grip. They pull life from whatever surfaces they cling to, while the roots, maybe, wither and rot until you cannot find the place from which the seed of the vine has truly sprung. That was my task: to uncover those earliest roots. And he had directed me to the seedbed.

The portrait that they and Natan paint is one of a boy, and later a man, who is brave, intelligent and fierce but also powerful, ruthless and unforgiving. The story of how he and Natan meet is a good example of this: Natan has fallen asleep tending his father’s flock of sheep and goats. When they wander into David’s camp, David prevents his men from preparing stew and rounds the animals up. He tells Natan what he has done and sends a message to Natan’s father, via Natan, that David and his men would be glad of provisions. Natan’s father refuses, calling David a traitor to the king.

At dawn I walked through my father’s blood and stood face-to-face with his killer. David had come in the dark, swift and silent. He slew my father and my uncle Barack with the dispatch of a slaughter man attending to his trade.

It’s at this point that Natan speaks his first prophecy and becomes part of David’s band of men.

The novel details the battles, the shifting allegiances, the power struggles, Natan’s prophesies and the coming-of-age of David’s sons. It also gives voice to David’s wives, detailing his treatment of them, the part they play in his quest for power and, particularly in the case of Batsheva, the misconceptions that surround their tales. For me, the reframing of the women’s stories, from tales of seduction to those that demonstrate the brutality of a powerful man are what makes this novel stand out from many historical fiction texts. Although the narrator is male, Brooks ensures that the women’s stories are foregrounded where they fit into the overall narrative arc.

Indeed, in most of our important histories, it’s rare enough for wives to be named, never mind the state of their affections noted. So I set it down as she had requested.

Yesterday I said that the Bailey’s Prize longlist always produces a couple of gems and this is another of them. I briefly heard of Geraldine Brooks when March won the Pulitzer but never ventured as far as reading any of her work. After the delight that is the mature, gripping, beautifully written The Secret Chord, I’ll be treating myself to her back catalogue.


Thanks to Little, Brown for the review copy.

14 thoughts on “The Secret Chord – Geraldine Brooks

  1. Geraldine Brooks is one of my favourite novelists and this book made my top ten last year. Caleb’s Crossing and Year of Wonders are my two favourites.

    Liked by 1 person

    • I’m always concerned when people think an established author’s debut is still their best book but I do like the sound of it (partly because I don’t live that far from Eyam).


      • I’d put Andrew Miller in the same bracket. I hope you enjoy it as much as I did. In my ignorance I knew nothing about the way in which the Eyam villagers protected themselves which probably added to its interest for me.


  2. The premise of this novel does sound interesting. Initially it put me in mind of ‘The Red Tent’ which I loathed. It wasn’t the retelling of a Biblical story from the perspective of the women that irritated me, but the writing. Oh, and the fact that it went on to herald in an entire franchise of womb-centred women’s groups in its wake (I prefer my women’s groups political). Grrr. However, I thought ‘Year of Wonders’ was magnificent, so I’m sure the subject matter is in safe hands. Another one to look for in the library!

    Liked by 1 person

  3. I’ve read and loved all of her other books, but haven’t gotten to this one yet. It’s only a matter of time…
    Like most everyone else, my favourite of hers is Year of Wonders, then maybe People of the Book. But, they’re all good!

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Pingback: The Long Way to a Small Angry Planet – Becky Chambers | The Writes of Woman

    • Oh, that’s interesting. I bought YoW the other day. I would’ve read March a long time ago if I’d known that! I’m not a Little Women devotee and it was the thought that it was some sort of tribute that was putting me off. Brilliant, I’ll look out of her non-fiction. Thanks for commenting and I’ll take a look at your review.

      Liked by 1 person

  5. Pingback: The Bailey’s Women’s Prize for Fiction Longlist 2016 | The Writes of Woman

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s