Twenty books, five weeks, six readers and a lot of discussion later (some of it heated – ask six passionate readers how they each feel about a book and prepare to stand back!), here’s the Shadow Panel’s choices for the shortlist. (In alphabetical order by author.)
If you click on the books, they will take you to my reviews. My reviews of all the longlisted books are linked to here. Let us know what you think of our decisions. The official shortlist is announced tonight across all the Bailey’s Prize social media channels at 7.15pm.
Reblogged this on rennydiokno.com.
LikeLike
Ah, no Elizabeth is Missing or Station Eleven? I loved those books. But I also loved I am China and you weren’t a fan of that!
LikeLike
This was a panel decision so there had to be majority agreement on the books that made the shortlist. All three books you mention had at least one champion on the panel. One of our discussions was about books we loved that we weren’t sure they met all of the criteria set by the prize.
LikeLiked by 2 people
An interesting shortlist I’ve read other books by two of the writers Tyler and waters both of which I liked on the longlisted books
LikeLiked by 1 person
Can’t wait to see how the shadow list matches up with the ‘official’ list. I’ve been a bit slack in Bailey’s reading (currently reading the Australian Stella Prize shortlist) but figure I’ll get busy after the official announcement.
LikeLike
Look forward to your Stella Prize thoughts – will you be posting about them? (By the way, agree with you about Hausfrau, it should’ve been on the list.)
LikeLike
Yes, will be posting all my Stella reviews (in a flurry this week!).
Have a bad feeling that Hausfrau will be missing out on lots of shortlists… WHY?!
LikeLike
The reaction I’ve seen to Hausfrau suggests it’s a marmite book. In which case, it’s going to be dismissed if you’re on a panel isn’t it?
LikeLike
I think station eleven is an oversight too.
LikeLike
Considering we rarely agree on books…! 😉 How many of the list have you read, Trudi?
LikeLike
Really impressed by the time and effort to create the shadow panel – well done all of you! What a buzz it will be for you to see if your list matches theirs. I haven’t read all of the reviews (for fear I’d keep buying more books and add to my already mountainous tbr list!) but will do soon.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks, Helen. The thought of the real list is weird for me this year, I feel so invested in the outcome now!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Pingback: The Bailey’s Prize for Women Shortlist 2015 | The Writes of Woman
Pingback: The Baileys Women’s Prize for Fiction Shortlist 2016… | Savidge Reads
How exciting! A great list and set of reviews, look forward to seeing who you come up with for a winner.
LikeLike
Thanks Claire.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Pingback: Baileys Prize for Women’s Fiction Shortlist 2015 | book word
Pingback: The Bailey’s Women’s Prize for Fiction Shadow Panel Winner | The Writes of Woman