The Burgess Boys – Elizabeth Strout

One of the things recent events in Boston has highlighted is that people can be quick to jump to conclusions based on very little evidence, or – as some puppets on Avenue Q sang – ‘Everyone’s a Little Bit Racist’. Maybe ‘Everyone’s a Little Bit Ignorant of Other People’s Cultures’ might have been more factually accurate but often the outcomes are very similar.

Elizabeth Strout’s latest novel explores this idea through a wave of Somali immigration to the small town of Shirley Falls, Maine on America’s east coast. Shirley Falls was once home to the Burgess family – older brother Jim and twins, Bob and Susie. Jim left for New York as soon as their mother died, with Bob not long behind him. Susie has remained in Shirley Falls where she lives with her son, Zach, his father having left them and returned to his ancestral country of Sweden.

Early in the novel, Jim receives a telephone call from Susie which he relays to his wife, Helen and brother, Bob.

“Our nephew, Zachary Olson, has thrown a frozen pig’s head through the door of a mosque. During prayer. During Ramadan. Susan says Zach doesn’t know what Ramadan is, which is completely believable – Susan didn’t know what it was until she read about this in the paper. The pig’s head was bloody, starting to melt, it’s stained their carpet, and they don’t have the money to buy a new one. They have to clean it seven times because of the holy law. That’s the story, you guys.”

Helen looked at Bob. Puzzlement came to her face. “Why would that be all over the papers, Jim?” she finally asked, softly.

“Do you get it?” Jim asked, just as quietly turning to her. “It’s a hate crime, Helen.”

So the novel gains two major themes – that of immigration and ignorance, on both sides – and of family and what it means to be part of one, whether that be from the point of view of a spouse, a parent, a child, or a sibling.

The Burgess family is an interesting, although I would suggest fairly typical, family. Jim is a hot shot lawyer, still living off a big televised case some years previously. He married into money and continually feels the pressure to make sure that he’s earning and paying the family’s way. Bob works in legal aid and is the butt of the family’s jokes – particularly Jim who continually jibes him, referring to him as ‘slob dog’ and calling his apartment a ‘graduate dorm’. Bob was responsible, aged 4, for a tragic accident which killed their father, something he has had to bear all his life. Suzie works in a shop and has a lodger – Mrs. Drinkwater – to help make ends meet.

The Burgess Boys is a mature novel that successfully explores the actions and reactions of a family in crisis. Through the family members and the people closest to them, Strout creates a group of fully rounded humans who bicker and support and hurt each other and love. The focus on the family means that the issue of immigration and cultural understanding never threatens to overwhelm the novel and make it feel as though Strout is preaching to us as opposed to telling a story. This is an engaging novel well worthy of a few hours of your time.

Thanks to Random House (US) for the proof copy.

9 thoughts on “The Burgess Boys – Elizabeth Strout

  1. Your first paragraph just nailed it, Naomi. You can’t imagine how angry I got when everyone blamed who they initially blamed.

    I heard of this book but it didn’t catch my attention.


    • Thanks, Elena.

      I didn’t know that it had a theme of immigration – the bits I’d read about it concentrated on the family and, although it’s very much a novel about family, the crisis over Zach’s actions becomes the centre of it and everyone’s reactions to that are fascinating. It’s well worth a read.


  2. I hadn’t thought of the Burgess family as ‘typical’ but maybe you are right in the sense that many families probably have underlying tension that come to the fore in times of crisis. The Burgess Boys is a relatively short and simply told story but has a depth and complexity in the themes and characterisation that make it a satisfying read.


    • Hi Izzy

      I think I meant they were typical in the way they related to each other: that sibling ‘banter’ that can sometimes be very cutting. The way they’ve all made quite different choices about their lives.

      Maybe my family’s atypical though!


  3. Pingback: The Bailey’s Women’s Fiction Prize Longlist 2014 | The Writes of Woman

  4. This was my first (but definitely not my last) Strout. I was very impressed how she drew me into reading about and caring so many characters that at first glance appeared very unlikeable. She doesn’t judge and explain; she digs deep and reveals.


  5. Pingback: My Name Is Lucy Barton – Elizabeth Strout | The Writes of Woman

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s